| Season | Winner | Runner-up |
|---|---|---|
| '24 Spring | Matt Rua | Chris Lucas |
| '23 Spring | Jean Zorilla | Brandon Gibson |
| '22 Fall | Mike Kamysz | David Seamans |
| '22 Spring | Sam Gilot | Rikko Lott |
| '21 Fall | Eric Williams | Niko Badillo |
| '21 Spring | Chris Guillermo | Edwin Rodriguez |
| '20 Fall | Cory White | David Landry |
| '19 Fall | Ben Glassman | Pat Morris |
| '19 Spring | Steve Riley | Steve Tambouris |
| '18 Fall | Nkongolo Harmel | Jesse Diaz |
| '18 Spring | Ben Phelps | Tim Nutter |
| '17 Fall | John McCarthy | Jay Smooth |
| '17 Spring | Tyler Baker | Ben Glassman |
| '16 Fall | AJ McKelvey | Joey Lorento |
| '16 Spring | Danny Connolly | Mike Lamonday |
| '15 Fall | Nate Cathcart | Cory White |
| '15 Spring | Dylan Humphrey | Danny Labrecque |
| '14 Fall | Joe Daly | Eugene Sartin |
| '14 Spring | Shawn Morin | Ryan Rule |
| '13 Fall | Scott Stankiewicz | Adam Gill |
| '13 Spring | Tai Ahmad | Tony Longhi |
| '12 Fall | Mike Dion | Joe Dejardins |
| '12 Spring | Nico Couture | Leslie Traeger |