| Season | Belt# | Winner | Score | Loser | Playoff MVP | Reg. Season MVP |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fall '23 | XXVI | F.T.B. | 31-12 | Shotgunnaz | Bryce Sturtevant | Jason Michelini |
| Spring '23 | XXV | Vikings | 39-12 | Legion of Doom | Jake Forsaith | David Hamilton |
| Fall '22 | XXIV | SoloTouch | 26-14 | Raiders | Andrew Duval | Jay Charles |
| Spring '22 | XXIII | SoloTouch | 14-12 | R.O.D. | Andrew Duval | Andrew Duval |
| Fall '21 | XXII | R.O.D. | 32-14 | Suicide Squad | Jay Smooth | Melvin Bonilla |
| Spring '21 | XXI | Rampage | 27-19 | Raiders | James Tanguay | Andrew Duval |
| Fall '20 | XX | R.O.D. | 36-28 | Shake n' Bake | Rob Keddie | Andrew Duval |
| Spring '20 | XIX | Covid | 19-0 | Everyone | --- | --- |
| Fall '19 | XVIII | Tigers | 13-6 | Carnage | AJ Rotella | AJ Labrecque |
| Spring '19 | XVII | Rage | 21-14 | Legion of Doom | Dave Martel | Dan Walkley |
| Fall '18 | XVI | n/a | 0-0 | n/a | Matt Bailey | Dan Walkley |
| Spring '18 | XV | Vikings | 26-20 OT | Athletes | Jake Forsaith | Nate Forsaith |
| Fall '17 | XIV | Rage | 27-25 | Vikings | Joe Harris | Dane Schindler |
| Spring '17 | XIII | Rage | 32-7 | Flagnado | Erik Johnson | Jamaal Woods |
| Fall '16 | XII | Tigers | 26-20 OT | Punishers | AJ Rotella | Deuce Jennings |
| Spring '16 | XI | Vikings | 32-26 OT | Blue Balls | Jake Forsaith | Jamaal Woods |
| Fall '15 | X | Rage | 32-14 | Vikings | Jamaal Woods | Jake Forsaith |
| Spring' 15 | IX | Rage | 45-18 | Blue Balls | Rob Keddie | Jay Vance |
| Xtreme '15 | VIII | Blue Barracudas | 26-25 | Pug Life | Billy Dubois | Nick Sapienza |
| Fall '14 | VII | Vikings | 37-18 | Storm | Greg Matthews | Dan Walkley |
| Spring '14 | VI | Vikings | 36-30 | Blue Balls | Vikings 6th Man | Bill Savary |
| Fall '13 | V | Scoregasms | 25-18 | Rough Riders | Dan Walkley | Codey Dalton |
| Spring '13 | IV | Fan Faves | 20-13 | Goats | Kevin Langevin | Jerry Brown |
| Fall '12 | III | Fan Faves | 28-27 | Rough Riders | Justin Gagne | Tai Ahmad |
| Spring' 12 | II | Fan Faves | 35-28 | Rough Riders | Chris George | Chuck Ford |
| Fall '11 | I | Rough Riders | 49-42 | Kibbles n'Vick | Mario Pena | Chuck Ford |
B division history
| Season | Blitzen Appearance | Winner | Score | Loser |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fall'23 | Seventeen | Goya Beanz | 13-6 | Scoregasms |
| Spring '23 | Sixteen | Greek Gods | 14-13(OT) | Shotgunnaz |
| Fall '22 | Fifteen | Most Wanted | 29-28(OT) | Goya Beanz |
| Spring '22 | Fourteen | Golden Boys | 40-27 | Nightmare |
| Fall '21 | Thirteen | Flagnado | 29-20 | Nightmare |
| Spring '21 | Thirteen | Raw Talent | 20-14 | Nightmare |
| Fall '20 | Twelve | Scoregasms | 4-1 | Battletoads |
| Fall '19 | Eleven | Raiders | 35-28 | Flagnado |
| Spring '19 | Ten | Vinegar Strokes | 7-0 | Scoregasms |
| Fall '18 | Nine | Tigers | 20-8 | Vinegar Strokes |
| Spring '18 | Eight | Blue Balls of Doom | 14-0 | Tigers |
| Fall '17 | Seven | Battletoads | 21-7 | Young Dynasty |
| Spring '17 | Six | Battletoads | 7-0 | Flagnado |
| Fall '16 | Five | Goonies | 37-32 | Battletoads |
| Spring '16 | Four | Punishers | 20-13 | Scoregasms |
| Fall '15 | Three | Outlawz | 8-0 | America's Children |
| Spring '15 | Two | Tigers | 28-7 | Bangarang |
| Fall '14 | One | Battletoads | 40-7 | Dream Team |