(best sportsmanship in the league)
| Season | Winner | Runner-up |
|---|---|---|
| '24 Spring | Nick Lanza | Marke Perry |
| '23 Fall | Bailey Cutter | Huncho |
| '23 Spring | Leon Henderson | Matt Rua |
| '22 Fall | Jason Posnick | Stephen Gibson |
| '22 Spring | Jamaal Woods | Nocturnal Knights |
| '21 Fall | David Choate | Scott Nightingale |
| '21 Spring | Johnny Granfield | Tyler McDaniels |
| '20 Fall | Drew Norris | Jesse Fortier |
| '19 Fall | Arron Witkus | Mike Howe |
| '19 Spring | Felix Torres | John Freese |
| '18 Fall | Evan White | Devon Collier |
| '18 Spring | Joe Page | Pat O'Donnell |
| '17 Fall | Jerry Brown | Jake Tinirella |
| '17 Spring | Kiel Canada | Darrin Standish |
| '16 Fall | Tyler Tripodi | Drew Norris |
| '16 Spring | Jerry Brown | Tyler Tripodi |
| '15 Fall | Ross Pepin | Ben Glassman |
| '15 Spring | Jovi Santos | Tyler Shattuck |
| '14 Fall | Scott French | Matt Arpin |
| '14 Spring | Johnny Nadeau | John Linnehan |
| '13 Fall | Zach Breen | John Colon |
| '13 Spring | Bill Savary | Johnny Nadeau |
| '12 Fall | Washington Morisset | Nick Sapienza |
| '12 Spring | Tobias Hubbard | Chris Fabri |