| Season | Winner | Runner-up |
|---|---|---|
| '24 Spring | Jerry Brown | Dane Schindler |
| '23 Fall | Jason Michelini | Tyler McDaniels |
| '23 Spring | David Hamilton | JJ Lopez |
| '22 Fall | Jay Charles | David Hamilton |
| '22 Spring | Andrew Duval | Riley Cote |
| '21 Fall | Melvin Bonilla | Ivan Quijano & Riley Cote |
| '21 Spring | Andrew Duval | JJ Lopez |
| '20 Fall | Andrew Duval | George Notini |
| '19 Fall | AJ Labrecque | Jerry Brown |
| '19 Spring | Dan Walkley | Jerry Brown |
| '18 Fall | Dan Walkley | Kiel Canada |
| '18 Spring | Nate Forsaith | Jake Tinirella |
| '17 Fall | Dane Schindler | Scott French |
| '17 Spring | Jamaal Woods | Bill Savary |
| '16 Fall | Dee Jennings | Dan Walkley |
| '16 Spring | Jamaal Woods | AJ Labrecque |
| '15 Fall | Jake Forsaith | Rob Keddie |
| '15 Spring | Jay Vance | Billy Dubois |
| '15 XTreme | Nick Sapienza | Dave Martel |
| '14 Fall | Dan Walkley | Billy Savary |
| '14 Spring | Bill Savary | Jerry Brown |
| '13 Fall | Codey Dalton | Dave Martel |
| '13 Spring | Jerry Brown | Kevin Langevin |
| '12 Fall | Tai Ahmad | Justin Gagne |
| '12 Spring | Chuck Ford | Justin Gagne |
| '11 Fall | Chuck Ford | Mario Pena |
Playoff MVP
| Season | Winner |
|---|---|
| '24 Spring | Niko Badillo |
| '23 Fall | Bryce Sturtevant |
| '23 Spring | Jake Forsaith |
| '22 Fall | Andrew Duval |
| '22 Spring | Andrew Duval |
| '21 Fall | Jay Smooth |
| '21 Spring | James Tanguay |
| '20 Fall | Rob Keddie |
| '19 Fall | AJ Rotella |
| '19 Spring | Dave Martel |
| '18 Fall | Matt Bailey |
| '18 Spring | Jake Forsaith |
| '17 Fall | Joe Harris |
| '17 Spring | Erik Johnson |
| '16 Fall | AJ Rotella |
| '16 Spring | Jake Forsaith |
| '15 Fall | Rob Keddie / Jamaal Woods |
| '15 Spring | Rob Keddie |
| '15 XTreme | Billy Dubois |
| '14 Fall | Greg Matthews |
| '14 Spring | Vikings 6th Man |
| '13 Fall | Dan Walkley |
| '13 Spring | Kevin Langevin |
| '12 Fall | Justin Gagne |
| '12 Spring | Chris George |
| '11 Fall | Mario Pena |