(offensive player of the year)
| Season | Winner | Runner-up |
|---|---|---|
| '24 Spring | Tyler McDaniels | Big Country |
| '23 Fall | Gavin Auger | JJ Lopez |
| '23 Spring | Adam Tambouris | Niko Badillo |
| '22 Fall | Brian Pacheco | Tom Scalley |
| '22 Spring | Brian Pacheco | David Hamilton |
| '21 Fall | Andrew Duval | Andre Rioux |
| '21 Spring | Jason Grace | Nathan Guillermo |
| '20 Fall | David Baldwin | Dan Walkley |
| '19 Fall | John McCarthy | David Hamilton |
| '19 Spring | Alex Golden | Brandon Gomes |
| '18 Fall | Melvin Bonilla | Garrett Nelson |
| '18 Spring | Bill Savary | Dee Jennings |
| '17 Fall | Kiel Canada | Craig Maynard |
| '17 Spring | Dez Manning | David Zocco |
| '16 Fall | Dan Walkley | Kevin Langevin |
| '16 Spring | Nate Forsaith | Vinnie Frasco |
| '15 Fall | Tim Doss | Vinnie Frasco |
| '15 Spring | Brian Bebyn | Nate Forsaith |
| '14 Fall | Jerry Brown | Kiel Canada |
| '14 Spring | Nate Forsaith | Bill Savary |
| '13 Fall | Leon Lackiram | Ivan Valcarel |
| '13 Spring | Dan Walkley | Mike Dion |
| '12 Fall | Tai Ahmad | Jake Tinirella |
| '12 Spring | Justin Gagne | Leon Lackiram |
| '11 Fall | Ramon Pena | Zach Lockwood |