| Season | Winner |
|---|---|
| '24 Spring | Jose Montanez II |
| '23 Fall | CJ Burke |
| '23 Spring | Danny Cruz |
| '22 Fall | JT Strickland |
| '22 Spring | Greg Balamotis |
| '21 Fall | Ronnie Pena |
| '21 Spring | Brian Pacheco |
| '20 Fall | Tyler Humphrey |
| '19 Fall | Jason Grace |
| '19 Spring | Vincente Zenni |
| '18 Fall | Ben Durand |
| '18 Spring | DJ Ramos |
| '17 Fall | Chris Rocker |
| '17 Spring | Jay Smooth |
| '16 Fall | Tyler Baker |
| '16 Spring | John McCarthy |
| '15 Fall | Jordan Martin |
| '15 Spring | Rob Keddie |
| '14 Fall | Matt Thomas |
| '14 Spring | Kiel Canada |
| '13 Fall | Billy Dubois |
| '13 Spring | Adam Gill |
| '12 Fall | Dom Puleo |
| '12 Spring | Jordan Scott |